e-lawresources
Providing resources for studying law
 
Custom Search
   Home      R v Watson
 
R v Watson [1989] 2 All ER 865 Court of Appeal

The appellant smashed a window and broke into the house of an 87 year old man, Harold Moyler. Moyler went to investigate and the appellant shouted abuse at him and ran off. The police arrived and Moyler suffered a heart attack and died 90 minutes after the initial break in.

Held:

His conviction was quashed as it could not be established that the break in was the cause of the heart attack. However, the Court of Appeal held that a sober and reasonable person would regard the act of the appellant as dangerous as they would have known of the age and frail condition of the victim.
 
Back to lecture outline on constructive manslaughter