E-law cases
Custom Search
   Case summaries      Cichon v DPP

Cichon v DPP [1994] Crim LR 918 Divisional Court

A dog owner removed the muzzle from his pit bull terrier whilst in public as the dog was suffering from kennel cough. His conviction for allowing a pit bull terrier to be in a public place without being muzzled under s.1(2)(d) Dangerous Dogs Act 1991 was upheld.

Schiemann J:

“The Act does not in terms allow the person in control of the dog to make a value judgment as between what is good for the dog and what is good for the rest of mankind. We have here an absolute prohibition and a breach of that prohibition is to be followed by an order for the dog’s destruction, however blameless the dog and its owner”
Back to lecture outline on the defence of necessity in criminal law